< On choosing optimism?

It can be easy to consider optimism the naive or simply ignorant choice. Pessimism, by contrast, feels like the clear-eyed, realistic view.

I don't think that's true. At least not for me.

For many (most?) of us, pessimism is our default thinking. And increasingly I find myself spiralling towards things I find negative[1]. For me, optimism is harder. You have to risk being wrong[2][3].

Not naive optimism. As Rebecca Solnit put it, hope "is an axe you break down doors with in an emergency"[4]. It's choosing to work toward something better despite knowing it might fail. It's about saying "how can I make this better?".

Take a concrete example. AI is currently blowing up Software Engineering. Many engineers are rightly concerned their careers (as they know them) will no longer exist[5]. For many this is a real source of grief, which I share.

On the other hand, I've seen people building software who have never had access before. More people are getting to enjoy a form of building that I've enjoyed most of my life. This is transformative, and pretty damn fun.

There are real challenges. Choosing optimism doesn't mean I ignore those; it's about where I put my energy to have the most positive impact.

Also read: Having a Senior Moment and A Demographic Collapse of Developers.

Discuss and share via the meta page . Filed under AI, and People.

Footnotes

  1. This feels easier to do lately. Turns out it is. Widely cited paper Bad Is Stronger Than Good shows that negative events have a greater psychological impact than positive ones across nearly every domain. ↩

  2. Brene Brown's Daring Greatly argues that vulnerability is courage. Optimism asks the same. ↩

  3. At Culture Amp one of our founding values is have the courage to be vulnerable. The phrasing around courage and vulnerability was very deliberate. ↩

  4. Rebecca Solnit, Hope in the Dark (2004 and 2016). ↩

  5. This is just one facet. There are real environmental, social, and political impacts that are hard to ignore. ↩